Area guide · The off season

Winter up here, month by month

Guests planning a first winter trip ask us which month to come. December and March up here have almost nothing in common, and the month you pick shapes the trip more than any other decision you make. Here is what each one actually does, plus the thing all 4 share: from November to April the peninsula stops asking for reservations.

A winter sunset turning wind-blown snow pink, with long tree shadows reaching across the drifts
A March sunset over the frozen lake, with the snow still deep enough to hold every shadow the low sun throws

The season nothing needs booking

Every guide we have written for the warm months carries the same warning in different clothes: book the parking, book the slot, book the boat. Winter cancels all of it. The Grotto's reservation system pauses from November to April and you register at the Cyprus Lake office instead, which is the whole subject of our Grotto in winter guide. The paid parking windows at Little Cove and Devil's Monument end in September. The ferry sails away in mid-October. The fire is the one thing winter does not simplify, because the municipality has rules year round and the fire guide is where they live.

The trade is real. Some roads stop being plowed, the tour boats stop running and the village mostly closes, and Tobermory in winter covers what stays open, where to walk and how to handle the drive and the groceries. But nothing up here sells out between November and April, and that changes the shape of a day before you have left the house.

The edge of the ice sheet meeting open turquoise water over limestone, seen from above
The ice edge from above. The same turquoise water people queue for in July, with nobody on it

December: the dramatic month

The lake is usually still open water well into the new year, so December is the month of weather rather than ice. Storms cross Lake Huron with nothing in the way, the first real snow lands on green cedar and the deer move in close to the roads and yards in their grey winter coats. The days are at their shortest, with sunset before 5 all month, so a December day holds one outing, finished by early afternoon. What December does best: storm watching, the first snowshoe of the year when the snow cooperates and holiday weeks that feel further from the city than the drive suggests.

A white-tailed buck with antlers standing in fresh snow between tree trunks at the edge of a yard
Late December. The deer browse the yard edges all winter and a buck this close is a December sight
The peninsula from above under the first snow of the season, forest to the horizon with a road cutting through and a half-frozen wetland
The last day of November from above. The wetlands catch first while the big lake stays open

January: the lake starts building

January is when the cold settles in and the ice show begins. Pancake ice rafts up along the shore, the shallow bays lock first and a cold snap will grow frost ferns across window glass overnight. Walk the same stretch of shoreline 2 days running and the sculpture has changed. The rule that carries the whole season is the one from the winter guide: nobody measures the ice for you and nobody should be on it. The photograph is taken from the rock, every time.

The thing to understand before you walk out is the ice shelf. What looks like the shore extending further than usual is a lip of ice built out over open water with nothing underneath it. Waves work at it from below all winter, so the edge is always thinner than the part you are standing on, and a fresh snowfall erases the line where solid ground stops. Shelves let go in slabs, without a crack to warn you, and the water under one is deep and moving. Stay back from any edge you cannot see the bottom of, keep children and dogs off it entirely, and treat the whole white margin between the land and the open water as the lake rather than the shore.

Pancake ice forming on open water beside a snow-covered limestone shore under a dawn sky
Mid-January, 8 in the morning. The lake assembling itself one plate at a time
Feather-shaped frost crystals grown across a window pane, lit gold by the dawn behind
What a hard overnight freeze leaves on the glass by morning
Spruces completely flocked with fresh snow around a small clearing, lit gold by the morning sky
The morning after an overnight snowfall in late January. The trees hold it for days when the cold holds

February: the month nobody books

February is the emptiest the peninsula gets. The holiday weeks are over, March break has not started and the roads belong to the people who live here. It is also the deep of it. The snowpack peaks, the sun starts carrying some strength again and a hard blue February day after a January of grey feels like a different country.

This is the snowshoe month, and snowshoeing is the most underrated thing a visitor can do up here, mostly because there is nothing to learn. It is walking with bigger feet: 5 minutes of adjustment, no technique and no fitness barrier beyond an ordinary walk. You do not need a trail either. A field, a shoreline or a road the plow ignores is the route, and the silence 10 minutes in is the part people mention afterward. In February you can walk all of it without meeting anybody, which is the whole argument for coming now rather than in July.

A lone snowshoer crossing a vast expanse of wind-sculpted snow under a bright blue sky
Mid-February, the whole white world to yourself
Looking down at traditional wooden snowshoes mid-stride on packed snow, a second pair carried ahead
The whole technique, learned in the first 5 minutes of the first walk
4 traditional wooden snowshoes standing upright in a snowbank, backlit by low sun through pines
Traditional wooden ones work as well as they did 100 years ago. Ask whether a set lives at the cottage you are renting

March: the one we would argue for

March is the sleeper. The sun is properly strong, the days pass 12 hours at the equinox and the evening opens right up: sunset is quarter past 6 on March 1 and close to 8 by the 31st. An hour of that arrives in a single night when the clocks go forward, and the rest the month earns on its own. Either way the daily outing stops racing the dark. The snow holds far later than southern visitors expect, with deep drifts past the 21st in a normal year, but it settles and firms, which makes the easiest walking of the winter. South-facing forest floor starts to open, the deer come out to the first bare grass and the peninsula is bright and quiet at once. If what you want is the look of winter without the teeth of it, March is your month.

2 people walking through an open cedar and hardwood forest with patchy snow on the ground in March
Early March in the cedars, snow underfoot and green overhead
Thick pillows of fresh snow balanced on cedar sprigs above a sparkling drift, blue sky behind
Mid-March after a late storm. The snow is not done when the calendar says so
A red winter sunset under storm clouds, seen through bare trees above a frozen snow-covered shore
March, with the drifts still deep and the lake still white. The sky does this between storms all month
2 white-tailed deer grazing on a patch of bare grass at the snow line while snow falls
Late March. The deer find every bare patch the day it appears

What fills the days between the famous stops

  • Snowshoe from wherever you are. The best route is usually the shoreline or field you are already on, not a drive away. Ask your host whether snowshoes come with the cottage before you rent a set.
  • Walk the shore and watch the ice edge. Where open water meets the shelf changes daily and it is the best free show of the season. From the rock, and back from the edge, as above.
  • Read the fresh snow. An overnight fall prints the night's traffic by morning: deer, fox, squirrel and rabbit, and following one line of tracks to wherever it goes fills more of a morning than you would expect.
  • Keep the sunset appointment. It happens at walking-around hours all winter, and the sky that follows 40 minutes later is the one the dark sky guide calls the clearest of the year.
  • Light a fire in falling snow. It is a better version of the same evening, the crowds that come with a summer fire ban are not here, and the rules in the fire guide still apply. The wood still gets bought locally.
2 people far out on open snow in low evening sun, their shadows running long across the drifts
Late afternoon in March, with the sun still hours from setting. A month earlier this was nearly dark
A small campfire burning between 2 logs on packed snow, with deep snow and cedars behind
Snow underfoot changes nothing about the rules. The water bucket and the drowning-it rule hold all year
Broken ice plates over dark water seen straight down from above, a mosaic of white and grey shards
The ice sheet from above in mid-March, breaking into plates. From the shore its edge redraws itself daily

The photographs on this page come from 2 recent winters, the end of November through late March. That span is the point: the season is long, it is really 4 seasons and not one of them requires a reservation. Pick your month, and the rest of the planning is mostly groceries.

Golden sunset over a shore of broken ice plates and open water, seen from above with a forested headland
March 9, 7 in the evening. The ice goes out in plates, and sunset now happens at dinner instead of before it
Green daffodil tips pushing up through the last few centimetres of snow in strong spring sun
March 26. The daffodils come up through the last of it, snow or no snow

We live here through all 4 of these months and every photograph on this page is ours.